In this guide
If you have a self-managed super fund (SMSF), no doubt you’re aware you need to have your fund’s assets valued regularly to remain compliant with Australia’s super legislation.
Asset valuations are in the spotlight with the introduction of Division 296 tax from 1 July 2026. This new tax applies to the taxable super earnings of individuals whose total super balance (TSB) exceeds $3 million. Additional tax will only apply to the portion of individual balances above $3 million.
SMSF trustees have a one-off option to reset the capital gains tax (CGT) cost base of their fund’s assets to their market value on 30 June 2026, for Division 296 purposes only. The election must be made by the due date for lodging the fund’s 2026–27 annual return. Because the reset uses each asset’s market value on 30 June 2026, it’s important to have an accurate, well-documented valuation at that date.
While the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) generally accepts SMSF asset valuations that follow the guidelines, it may review valuations as part of its ongoing compliance monitoring. The overarching principle is that assets are reported at market value. So be sure you have evidence to support your valuations as well as documentation of the methods used.
What is market value?
The ATO defines market value as the following:
Market value is the estimated monetary worth of an asset on the open market at a particular time. It is based on:
- The most valuable use of the asset (which may be different from how it is currently used)
- The amount that a willing buyer and seller would agree to in an arm’s-length transaction.
Manage your SMSF smarter – for free
Access practical, independent guides and checklists to help you run your fund with confidence with a free SuperGuide account.
Find out moreWhy do assets need to be valued?
There are important legal reasons why SMSF assets need to be valued regularly, including for:
- Preparing the fund’s financial accounts and statements
- Determining the total super balance of fund members (that is, the balance of their accumulation and retirement accounts). Currently, if any fund member’s total super balance is $2.1 million or more on 30 June 2026, this affects their eligibility in 2026–27:
- to make non-concessional (after-tax) contributions
- to use the bring-forward rule for the non-concessional contributions cap
- for the government’s super co-contribution scheme
- for the spouse super contributions tax offset
- Ensuring that members don’t exceed their transfer balance cap (the general cap is $2.1 million from 1 July 2026) on funds that are moved from the accumulation phase to the retirement phase
- Determining fund member eligibility for carry-forward concessional contributions (your total super balance must be less than $500,000 on 30 June of the previous financial year)
- Ensuring any assets are acquired or transferred on an arm’s-length basis (at market values) to either related or unrelated parties
- Calculating the market value of the fund’s in-house assets (which cannot be more than 5% of the market value of the fund’s total assets). In-house assets are investments with (or loans made to) fund members or their related parties
- Ensuring that any collectable or personal use assets of the fund are disposed of at current market values
- Determining the value of assets that support an SMSF fund member’s pension.
What is the ATO’s recommended approach?
The table below provides the ATO’s guidelines on how different types of SMSF assets should be valued for different types of events.
| Event or asset | Valuation requirement |
|---|---|
| Preparing SMSF financial accounts and statements | All fund assets must be valued at market value, based on objective and supportable data. In some circumstances, a reasonable estimate may need to be made. |
| Calculating members’ total super balances | Market valuations need to be done on 30 June each year for assets supporting members’ retirement phase and accumulation accounts, based on objective and supportable data. |
| Collectables and personal use assets when sold or transferred to a related party | The market value of these assets must be determined by a qualified independent valuer. |
| Acquisition of an asset from a related party of the fund | All acquisitions must be made at market value based on objective and supportable data. |
| Disposal of an asset to a related party of the fund | Sale price should reflect a true market rate of return. |
| Determining the value of assets that support super pensions or income streams and, from 1 July 2017, count towards the transfer balance cap | The market value of these assets needs to be based on objective and supportable data on the day the pension is started or on 1 July in any year in which the pension is paid. In some circumstances, a reasonable estimate may need to be made. |
| Testing the market value of the fund’s in-house assets (to ensure they don’t exceed 5% of the value of the fund’s total assets) | The market valuation should be done on 30 June each year and based on objective and supportable data. |
| Determining market value of assets eligible for transitional CGT relief | Valuations must be based on objective and supportable data. |
| Listed securities (such as shares and listed managed funds) | These assets must be valued at their closing price on their approved stock exchange or market (such as the Australian Securities Exchange or ASX) on 30 June each year. |
| Unlisted securities (such as shares in private companies or units in unlisted trusts) | To determine market value, fund trustees (or an independent valuer) need to consider the value of the assets in the company or trust, the amount paid for the unlisted security, or both. |
| Real property | A valuation is not required each year, but it should be done if market conditions or other circumstances that may affect the property’s value have changed. For example, if renovations have been done to an investment property owned by the SMSF, or if the net income yield of a commercial property has changed. This valuation could be done via an independent appraisal or by researching recent selling prices of similar properties to use as comparable, objective valuation data. |
Who can value assets?
From the ATO’s point of view, it’s the valuation process that’s important rather than the person conducting it. SMSF trustees can generally value fund assets themselves, provided they use objective and supportable data as the basis for their valuations. The exception is collectables and personal use assets, where the services of a qualified independent valuer must be used.
Qualified independent valuers must be unrelated to any fund members and will likely have formal qualifications, professional knowledge and experience, or both in valuing specific types of assets.
Fund trustees have the option of using professional valuers for their other SMSF assets. The ATO recommends using a qualified valuer for assets that represent a significant proportion of the fund’s total value, or where the nature of the asset means valuation is likely to be complex.
SMSF auditors may also request an independent valuation of SMSF assets as part of their normal annual audit. SMSF auditors must be approved by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC).
Common SMSF valuation mistakes
Shirley Schaefer and Tenille Ireland from accounting firm BDO say most valuation problems come down to process and documentation rather than the final figure. Auditors and the ATO check how you arrived at a value at least as closely as the value itself.
These are the mistakes they see most often:
- Treating valuation as a one-off. Market value has to be supported every year. Even if an asset’s value hasn’t changed since last year, you need current evidence that shows why.
- Relying on a one-line letter from an agent. A letter from a local real estate agent can be acceptable for a property, but it needs to set out the valuation methodology and comparable sales. A single sentence on a letterhead stating a value is no longer enough.
- Using an out-of-date property valuation. The ATO’s view is that a valuation should be within about three months either side of 30 June. If it falls outside that window, keep evidence of what happened in the local market in the meantime.
- Skipping a sworn valuation when there are no comparable sales. Where similar properties rarely sell, such as farms in regional areas, the ATO’s view is that you will probably need a sworn valuation.
- Mismatched dates on off-market share transfers. Where the off-market transfer form is the only document used, the date of signing is the date for working out market value. Problems arise when the form uses a market value from a different date and the market has moved in between. A recent update to the ATO’s ruling TR 2010/1 means you can record the correct market value in the fund’s accounts even if the form was completed incorrectly.
- Using the wrong approach for unlisted shares and units. If a private company or trust mainly owns property, its value largely comes down to that property, so property valuation principles apply. A trading business that is rarely or never traded is harder to value, and in extreme cases you may need a business valuation.
- Relying on your own opinion alone. Your knowledge of an asset is useful, but it isn’t evidence. You need verifiable data and a logical, documented method that your auditor can follow and agree with.
Watch the interview
In this video, Shirley and Tenille explain why getting valuations right matters for your total super balance, your minimum pension payments, non-arm’s length income (which is taxed at 45%) and the new Division 296 tax. They also cover what “market value” means in practice and the documentation you need to support it.
Why do valuations matter so much for an SMSF?
Valuations are important for a number of reasons. The first of this would be total super balance. So total super balance is a measure of all of your superannuation. And it determines how much, how much you can put in in terms of contributions. So obviously the higher the value, the less able you may be to be able to make contributions, the lower, the more able. So it is important to get it right. Obviously valuations also impact your member balance. So if you’re in pension phase, it impacts how much you have to draw down as a minimum pension each year. If transactions aren’t at market value and aren’t done on an arm’s length basis, then the ATO introduces or could deem the income to be non-arm’s length income, which is taxed at a whopping 45%. Nobody wants to pay 45% tax. And then lastly, with the new tax coming in, the Division 296 tax, obviously the measure of your total super balance determines whether you’re in or out of the system. So it is critical for those measurements.
What is commonly misunderstood about the term market value?
I think it’s not necessarily what market value is, but for SMSF purposes, the requirements to kind of meet that market value threshold and provide the appropriate amount of documentation and supportable data to verify that something is at market value. And just the general frequency that we’ve got to do it, it is an annual requirement. And so all that data needs to continually be provided every single year, but it needs to be relevant. So even if a market value hasn’t moved from year to year, you do need to continue to support why that has occurred and make sure you’ve got all that documentation for your auditor.
Do the ATO and auditors care more about how a figure is determined than the precise figure?
Yeah, it’s the process. You know, it’s, I mean, obviously it does need to be the right number. The auditor needs to ensure that it is fairly stated, but very much so because I mean, valuation is such a, it depends kind of answer. Every situation is unique, circumstances are unique. So it is important to document clearly the process thought process of the trustees, how they arrived at that number, because that’s what will be able to be checked, verified, supported by data.
For property valuations, what sort of documentation is seen as acceptable or not?
There are lots of different ways that you can get that evidence to support a market value, including like property is probably a big one where it doesn’t have to be that licensed valuation that can often cost a lot of money. So a letter from a real estate agent, a local real estate agent, would be acceptable provided they had that expertise to be able to provide that valuation. But it’s important that it does set out that valuation methodology, the reasoning as to how they’ve come to that valuation. It is no longer acceptable to have a one sentence on a letterhead that says, I think that your property is valued at this. It does need to be supported by other information, valuation methodology, and comparable sales.
How recent do property valuations need to be?
Certainly the ATO’s view is sort of three months either side of the end of the year. It probably also then depends upon if there’s been market movement. So I think most trustees and auditors are happier that if it’s outside that timeframe, so long as you’ve supported what might have happened in that local market in that period of time, you can then almost re-engineer or backwards engineer what it is. But again, supported by verifiable data, not just, I think it’s gone up 15%.
How should trustees support a property valuation when comparable sales are scarce?
That’s harder because obviously comparable sales is the most common way of supporting a property valuation. I mean, if there’s truly been none, certainly the ATO view is you probably need a sworn valuation. And that can be very difficult. And certainly I know we’ve seen clients in farming properties in regional areas where there aren’t a lot of sales or farms are passed from father to son and nothing ever gets sold. Your sworn valuation is probably the way you have to go.
Why do off-market share transfers create valuation and compliance issues for SMSFs?
I think the form itself creates sort of a bit of a problem for the fact that it does allow you to put two different dates on it. So the main issue that we’re seeing with those off-market transfer forms is the date, when the date of transfer and the date of signing don’t align to each other. If that is, if the off-market transfer form is the only document that’s been executed to effect the transfer between two parties, then it’s the date of signing that we take to be that CGT date and therefore the date that you need to ascertain the market value of that transfer. Often we see people putting in the market value on the transfer date that they’ve signed selected, which can quite often be a couple of days different. We’ve seen it be a few weeks different. And where the market has moved and that price is no longer the market value on that date, then you’re no longer dealing with yourself at, on arm’s length terms, and that can potentially create gnarly issues. Fortunately, the ATO have recently updated their TR 2010/1 ruling, which allows you to replace the market value that you’ve used.
So even if the form has been completed incorrectly, you can actually just put the correct market value into your accounts, tick that box, and there’s no issues from that perspective. So that’s been a really good sort of change from the ATO to help people out because we see more often than not that these forms just aren’t completed correctly.
For unlisted shares or private company investments, what’s the minimum level of documentation?
That’s a hard one because it really is an it depends because they are quite different. I split private entities into really two categories. There’s the property owning entities, companies or trusts. Value is then probably heavily dependent on the asset. So you go back to your property valuation principles to work out the market value of shares or units. But if the entity is a trading company or runs a business or does something else, it makes it more difficult. If those shares are traded, so it’s more widely held, then obviously the value of the more recent trades can give you market value because that’s what somebody will pay for the shares. But if it’s not widely traded or it’s not traded at all, it makes it very difficult. And certainly in very extreme circumstances, you may actually need to go and get a business valuation. And that’s an expensive exercise for trustees. So you need to think about what the company does or the trust does, and then where is the value in that, in those operations.
If a valuation is challenged, what documentation should trustees have to support it?
Comes back to the documentation. The ATO’s little catchcry on valuations is objective and supportable data. So, so long as the auditor can see what it is you’ve relied on and how you’ve relied on it, generally that will be accepted. I always say that, you know, auditors aren’t necessarily smarter than anyone else unless they have some inherent knowledge about a particular asset, investment, location, whatever. If you set out a logical process, you can explain it to someone else, you’ve got the documentation and the data to back it up, then generally it is the process that’s important far more than the actual value.
If trustees remember just one rule about SMSF valuations, what should it be?
I think it’s about that documentation. Your accountant’s going to ask for it, the auditor’s going to ask for it. It’s perfectly fine for a trustee to have an opinion, and quite often we find trustees have a certain level of expertise about the asset that they’re talking about, especially with property. It’s not enough to say, based on my expertise, it’s this. You do really then need to go and get that data, that verifiable information, and sort of work through those data sources to make sure that an auditor can come along and agree with that valuation methodology and that logic. As we’ve said, it’s not about the number, then it’s not about questioning the number. It’s about questioning that methodology and that documentation that sits behind it to go, does this properly support that information?
Step-by-step guide to valuing your fund’s assets
So how should SMSFs go about valuing their assets? Here’s our five-step guide:
Step 1: Assess your SMSF’s holdings
Get the valuation of your listed assets in order. This is likely to be as simple as assessing your trading value on the last day of the financial year. This should give you an understanding of the proportion of your fund invested in listed and non-listed assets. Even if you are not sure of the current value of your unlisted assets, the price you paid for them should give you some idea of whether it makes up a significant percentage of your fund.
Step 2: Work out whether you need to pay to get an asset professionally valued
This will depend on what proportion of the fund the asset represents or if the nature of the asset indicates the valuation is likely to be complex, such as a boat or a boating club membership. If most of your SMSF is invested in property, then you need to seriously consider a professional valuation for that asset.
Step 3: Get the asset valued
Unlike auditors (who must be approved by ASIC), you only need to use a qualified independent valuer in certain instances (see Step 4). Otherwise, a valuation can be conducted by one of the following:
- A registered valuer
- A professional valuation service provider
- A member of a recognised professional valuation body
- A person without formal valuation qualifications but who has specific experience or knowledge in a particular area.
Step 4: Use a qualified independent valuer if required
Collectables and personal-use assets must be valued by a qualified independent valuer. Collectables and personal-use assets include (but are not limited to) artwork, jewellery, antiques, coins, medallions or bank notes, rare folios, manuscripts or books, memorabilia, wine or spirits, recreational boats and memberships of sporting or social clubs.
Step 5: Get the asset revalued as required
Sometimes, such as for real property, unless a major event or other circumstance affects the valuation, you will not need an external independent valuation every year. A new valuation will be required if the trustee believes the value of the property has been materially affected by, for example, a natural disaster or renovation. Just because an external valuation is not technically required every year doesn’t mean a valuation is set and forget. You should consider whether your valuations for unlisted assets are up to date and accurate every year. Your auditor may also suggest that it’s time for a new valuation when they do your accounts.
For real property valuations, the ATO suggests the following as sources of evidence:
- Independent appraisals from a real estate agent (kerb side)
- Contract of sale if the purchase is recent and no events have occurred to the property that could materially impact its value since the purchase
- Recent comparable sales results
- Rates notice (if consistent with other evidence on valuation)
- Net income yield of commercial properties (not sufficient evidence on their own and only appropriate where tenants are unrelated).
Just one of the above on its own is not likely to provide sufficient evidence, so it is best to provide a number of these documents.
The bottom line
Accurate asset valuation is an essential ingredient in ensuring your SMSF complies with super legislation. SMSF assets must be valued at their current market value, either by the fund’s trustees or independent professional valuers. The exception is the valuation of collectables and personal use SMSF assets, which must be valued by an independent professional. If SMSF trustees choose to value other types of assets themselves, they must base their valuation on objective data.


Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.