Guide to SMSF audits

Self-managed super fund (SMSF) audits are mandatory in Australia and must be conducted by an auditor who is registered with the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC).

This auditor must be independent (i.e. not have any financial interest in the SMSF, nor have any personal or business relationships with fund members or trustees).

An SMSF auditor is responsible for analysing a fund’s financial statements and assessing its compliance with superannuation law. They must report any non-compliance issues to all fund trustees and the ATO.

How often does your SMSF need to be audited?

Currently, an SMSF must be audited annually, and the trustees of an SMSF must appoint an approved auditor at least 45 days before their fund’s annual return to the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) is due. It’s important to understand that an audit is required even if no contributions have been made to the fund and no benefits have been paid in a financial year.

Proposed three-year audit cycle

In the 2018/2019 Federal Budget the government proposed that from 1 July 2019, the annual SMSF auditing requirement be changed to once every three years for SMSFs with a history of good record-keeping and compliance. This proposed change has been widely criticised across the SMSF industry (not just by SMSF auditors), and also by SMSF trustees. See the following SuperGuide articles for further information.

• SMSFs: 3 year audits policy will not benefit trustees and will add to complexity
• SMSFs: 3 year audits policy undermines integrity of the system
• SMSFs: What are the consequences of the 3 yearly audits policy?

Under the proposal, SMSFs that are approved for three-yearly audits would have all of their fund’s transactions for the previous three years audited, rather than just the previous year as happens with the annual auditing process.

To be eligible for a three-yearly audit cycle rather than an annual audit, SMSFs would need to have submitted their annual returns on time to the ATO for the previous three years and been assessed by their auditor as having been fully compliant with all super legislation during that time period.

However, if an SMSF moves to a three-year audit cycle under the new legislation, they will still be required to have an audit in the year in which any “key event” occurs. Common examples of such key events would be:

• A member of the fund commencing a super pension income stream for the first time
• A member of the fund dying
• The addition of a new fund member
• The removal of a fund member
• The commencement of a limited recourse borrowing arrangement by the fund
• Any in-specie asset transfers made to fund members

Important: This proposed legislation has not passed through parliament, so may not be in place by 1 July 2019.

What are the average costs for an SMSF audit?

The table below shows the average and median costs of an SMSF audit in 2015/2016 (the most recent figures available). These figures have been calculated by the ATO based on audit fees and expenses reported on SMSF annual returns. Remarkably, the median audit fee has remained at $550 for the last five financial years.

SMSF auditor fees	2012/2013	2013/2014	2014/2015	2015/2016	2016/2017
Average auditor fees	$737	$726	$760	$703	$688
Median auditor fee	$550	$550	$550	$550	$550

Source: Australian Taxation Office

The following table shows the proportion of SMSFs that fall within a variety of auditing fee ranges. As you can see, the vast majority of funds have annual audit fees of less than $1,000.

Audit fee range	2012/2013	2013/2014	2014/2015	2015/2016	2016/2017
$0 to $499	36.8%	36.5%	36.5%	36.9%	37.6%
$500 to $999	47.8%	48.9%	49.7%	50.2%	50.4%
$1,000 to $1,999	12.0%	11.5%	11.0%	10.5%	9.8%
$2,000 and above	3.4%	3.1%	2.8%	2.4%	2.1%

Source: Australian Taxation Office

What factors affect the cost of an SMSF audit?

There are a number of factors than can affect the cost of an SMSF audit, including:

• The complexity of the fund’s operations. For example, whether “key events” (see above) have occurred during an audit year.
• The number of members of the fund. SMSFs can currently have between one and four members. Another proposal from the 2018/2019 Federal Budget was to allow up to six members in an SMSF from 1 July 2019, but this legislation has not yet passed into law.
• The number and frequency of the fund’s investment transactions.
• Whether any fund members are in the retirement phase.
• The effectiveness of fund trustee record-keeping systems and processes.
• How long the fund has been operating. For example, there may be more auditing work in the fund’s first year of operation to ensure that it has been set up correctly.

How to find an SMSF auditor

You can search for an SMSF auditor online via ASIC’s register. These auditors have a valid SMSF auditor number (SAN) that they are required to supply on any SMSF returns that they submit to the ATO.

According to the ATO, the number of SMSF auditors has decreased from 10,165 in 2012 to 5,814 in 2016. This is despite the number of SMSFs increasing during that period and reflects the fact that the SMSF audit industry is consolidating. For example, the number of auditors auditing more than 250 funds per year increased from 34% in 2012 to 45% in 2016.

What happens in an SMSF audit?

SMSF auditors conduct both a financial and compliance audit of an SMSF’s operations as part of their auditing process. The financial audit analyses all of the fund’s financial statements (i.e. balance sheet, income statement and member statement) based on Australian Auditing Standards. The compliance audit analyses the fund’s compliance with all superannuation legislation.

Upon completing their financial and compliance audits, an SMSF auditor must complete an independent auditor’s report document that the ATO provides. This report must be provided to the trustees of the SMSF within 28 days of the auditor receiving all relevant documentation. SMSF trustees should work with their auditor to rectify any breaches as soon as possible. It is one of the legal responsibilities of fund trustees to then submit their fund’s audited annual return to the ATO and to ensure any associated tax obligations are paid in full.

If there have been any breaches (contraventions) of super legislation revealed in the compliance audit, auditors must report them to the ATO within 28 days using an ATO-provided contravention report document. If any breaches remain unresolved, trustees should take advantage of the ATO’s early engagement and voluntary disclosure service for SMSFs.

SMSF trustees who voluntarily disclose any breaches before the ATO commences their own investigation of them have this disclosure taken into consideration when the ATO subsequently considers the potential range of penalties that may be imposed.

What documents will I need to provide for an SMSF audit?

SMSF trustees (or any professional advisers that they may have hired such as an accountant) must provide their auditor with all relevant documentation for their fund’s accounts and financial transactions for the financial year being audited. For example, all financial and bank statements for that period.

If the SMSF auditor requests any further information or documentation, trustees must provide this material within 14 days.

The bottom line

SMSF trustees are legally obliged to have their fund audited by an independent SMSF auditor to ensure their ongoing compliance with Australian super legislation. The ATO can impose a range of penalties for non-compliance, depending on the seriousness of the breach.

The information contained in this article is general in nature.