• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
SuperGuide

SuperGuide

Superannuation and retirement planning information

  • SuperGuide Premium
  • Account
  • Log In
  • SuperGuide Premium
  • Account
  • Log In
  • How super works
    • Super for beginners
    • Super rules
    • Employers guide to super
    • Super contributions
    • Super and tax
    • Accessing super
    • Super news
    • Women and super
    • Super tips and strategies
    • How-to guides
    • Super quizzes
    • Superannuation Q&As
    • Superannuation glossary
  • Super funds
    • Best performing super funds
    • Super fund rankings
    • Best performing pension funds
    • Pension fund rankings
    • Super fund average returns
    • Super investing strategies
    • Comparing super funds
    • Choosing a super fund
    • Choosing an investment option
    • Super fund fees
    • Insurance and super
    • Super fund profiles
  • SMSFs
    • SMSFs for beginners
    • SMSF administration
    • SMSF checklists
    • SMSF compliance
    • SMSF investing
    • SMSF pensions
    • SMSF strategies
    • SMSF Q&As
  • Plan your retirement
    • Retirement planning for beginners
    • When should I retire?
    • How long will I live?
    • How much super do I need?
    • Will I get the Age Pension?
    • How much will I spend in retirement?
    • Financial advice
    • Retiring overseas
    • Preparing for retirement
    • Retirement planning strategies
    • Retirement calculators and reckoners
  • In retirement
    • Income in retirement
    • Super lump sums
    • Super pensions
    • Age Pension
    • Working in retirement
    • Life in retirement
    • Senior concessions and services
    • Aged care
    • Estate planning
    • Super death benefits

Home / Super funds / Comparing super funds

Fund Performance: SMSFs vs APRA super funds

May 7, 2019 by Ben Hall Leave a Comment

Reading time: 3 minutes

On this page

  • Average ROA, by fund size, by year
  • So how does the ROA formula differ from the ROR formula?
  • Annualised adjusted net returns, 2012–2016

The debate about who wins the battle between SMSFs and APRA-regulated super funds is one that has emerged in recent years with the rapid increase in new SMSFs which is growing at around 14% per year.

So which of these two retirement income investment vehicles delivers the better investment returns, and why can one perform better than the other?

One would think that in this modern day of advanced data gathering there would be a definitive answer but unfortunately the answer is not that clear cut. This is mainly down to the fact there are two organisations (the ATO and APRA) collecting and publishing statistics on SMSFs and other super funds, and each uses different methods of measuring returns. The ATO measures ROA (Return on Assets), APRA measures ROR (Rate of Return), and they can produce quite different results. We’ll get to the difference between the two later in the article.

On average, SMSFs have delivered annual returns, minus fees and taxes, of around 5.7% in the decade to 2016 compared to 5.3% for APRA-regulated super funds over the same period.

So SMSFs win the first battle on points but when you dig down through the data, there are some interesting sub-plots which provide a better insight into this SMSFs vs super funds debate.

It could be reasoned that the difference in performance could be driven by superior investment performance by SMSFs within asset classes, by differences in the underlying asset allocation between the segments, or by differences in how returns data are collected and reported by the ATO and APRA.

The most recent ATO available only covers to 2016. The table below shows the return on assets (ROA) of SMSFs by asset size. The ROA is calculated by determining the net earnings, and comparing this to average assets during the financial year to determine the percentage return on assets.

Average ROA, by fund size, by year

Fund size

2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

$1 – $50k

-18.73%

-17.28%

-12.51%

-17.38%

-16.70%

>$50k – $100k

-9.93%

-5.17%

-2.78%

-6.84%

-7.28%

>$100k – $200k

-5.90%

0.83%

1.55%

-1.02%

-3.28%

>$200k – $500k

-2.52%

6.36%

5.88%

2.45%

-0.02%

>$500k – $1m

-0.41%

9.31%

8.33%

4.60%

1.37%

>$1m – $2m

0.67%

10.64%

9.59%

5.70%

2.15%

>$2m

1.49%

11.59%

11.29%

7.52%

4.27%

Source: ATO

This provides an interesting snapshot which suggests that the bigger the fund size, the better the return. But this ROA is different to the way APRA measures performance which is ROR, or rate of return.

Class, an SMSF administration software company, produced its own SMSF Benchmark Report in September 2018 which questioned the Productivity Commission’s (PC) methodology in measuring investment returns.

Source: Class

Note: APRA ROA and ROR figures, and the SMSF ROA figure are drawn from the Productivity Commission draft report and associated Technical Supplement. The SMSF ROR return was calculated by Class using publicly available ATO data.

The basic findings from that report is that Class maintains the PC underestimates SMSF returns because when it compared the performance of SMSFs to APRA-regulated funds, inconsistent formulae were applied.

So how does the ROA formula differ from the ROR formula?

The ATO Return on Assets (ROA) formula is conservative and always shows a worse result than the APRA Rate of Return (ROR) formula. The ATO treats contributions tax and insurance as expenses but APRA does not. The smaller the member balance, the higher the impact of the extra expenses.

In October 2018, The PC acknowledged these discrepancies, which were raised by Class and the SMSF Association, when it released its report titled “Investment Performance: Supplementary Analysis”. This analysis acknowledges the submissions from both Class and the SMSF Association, and considers the impact the APRA vs ATO formulae has on SMSF performance results.

“With the assistance of additional data provided by the ATO and Class Limited, the Commission confirmed this to be the case, with the aggregate impact on reported SMSF returns in the order of 1 percentage point a year. While full comparability of returns calculations remains elusive, the Commission has attempted to reduce the disparity by applying a simple adjustment to SMSF return data to make them more comparable with APRA return data”, the PC report conceded.

Basically what it all means is that as a whole, as mentioned above, the SMSF segment delivered slightly higher annual returns compared with APRA-regulated super funds (5.7% v 5.3%).

When broken down further, that broad assessment remains true, it needs to be noted that larger SMSFs have outperformed the APRA-regulated segment. However, many smaller SMSFs, with balances under $500,000, or about 42% of the segment, have produced lower investment returns than larger SMSFs.

Annualised adjusted net returns, 2012–2016

Source: Productivity Commission analysis of PC analysis of ATO data on SMSFs.

The above graph factored in an adjusted formula, as suggested by Class and the SMSF Association, and “new” SMSFs were defined as those which were established within the past two years.

Learn more about comparing super funds in the following SuperGuide articles:

Super funds with the lowest fees for life and TPD insurance

Super funds with the lowest fees for life and TPD insurance

January 20, 2021

How your super fund works and who’s who in your fund

How your super fund works and who’s who in your fund

January 4, 2021

Super and pension fund performance: Where does your fund rank?

Super and pension fund performance: Where does your fund rank?

November 12, 2020

How to compare super funds in 7 easy steps

How to compare super funds in 7 easy steps

October 1, 2020

List of APRA-regulated superannuation funds

List of APRA-regulated superannuation funds

April 1, 2020

What are the different types of super funds?

What are the different types of super funds?

March 9, 2020

Super and pension funds with the lowest fees

Super and pension funds with the lowest fees

February 13, 2020

How to benchmark your super fund

How to benchmark your super fund

January 4, 2020

What is MySuper, and which super funds are MySuper funds?

What is MySuper, and which super funds are MySuper funds?

February 24, 2019

Learn more about super fund performance in the following SuperGuide articles:

Monthly super fund performance Reckoner: Monthly returns for 5 investment categories

Monthly super fund performance Reckoner: Monthly returns for 5 investment categories

January 19, 2021

Super fund performance over 28 calendar years (to December 2020)

Super fund performance over 28 calendar years (to December 2020)

January 19, 2021

Annual super fund performance Reckoner: Annual returns for 5 investment categories

Annual super fund performance Reckoner: Annual returns for 5 investment categories

January 19, 2021

Super fund performance: Monthly returns to December 2020

Super fund performance: Monthly returns to December 2020

January 19, 2021

What are lifecycle super funds, and how do they perform?

What are lifecycle super funds, and how do they perform?

September 16, 2020

Pension fund performance to September 2020

Pension fund performance to September 2020

August 7, 2020

Superannuation funds: Does size really matter?

Superannuation funds: Does size really matter?

June 3, 2019

Related topics

Comparing super funds Super funds

IMPORTANT: All information on SuperGuide is general in nature only and does not take into account your personal objectives, financial situation or needs. You should consider whether any information on SuperGuide is appropriate to you before acting on it. If SuperGuide refers to a financial product you should obtain the relevant product disclosure statement (PDS) or seek personal financial advice before making any investment decisions. Comments provided by readers that may include information relating to tax, superannuation or other rules cannot be relied upon as advice. SuperGuide does not verify the information provided within comments from readers. Learn more

Primary Sidebar

How super works
Super for beginners
Super rules
Employers guide to super
Super contributions
Super and tax
Accessing super
Super news
Women and super
Super tips and strategies
How-to guides
Super quizzes
Superannuation Q&As
Superannuation glossary
Super funds
Best performing super funds
Super fund rankings
Best performing pension funds
Pension fund rankings
Super fund average returns
Super investing strategies
Comparing super funds
Choosing a super fund
Choosing an investment option
Super fund fees
Insurance and super
Super fund profiles
SMSFs
SMSFs for beginners
SMSF administration
SMSF checklists
SMSF compliance
SMSF investing
SMSF pensions
SMSF strategies
SMSF Q&As
Plan your retirement
Retirement planning for beginners
When should I retire?
How long will I live?
How much super do I need?
Will I get the Age Pension?
How much will I spend in retirement?
Financial advice
Retiring overseas
Preparing for retirement
Retirement planning strategies
Retirement calculators and reckoners
In retirement
Income in retirement
Super lump sums
Super pensions
Age Pension
Working in retirement
Life in retirement
Senior concessions and services
Aged care
Estate planning
Super death benefits
Compare super funds

Footer

Important: Disclaimer

All information on SuperGuide is general in nature only and does not take into account your personal objectives, financial situation or needs.

You should consider whether any information on SuperGuide is appropriate to you before acting on it.

If SuperGuide refers to a financial product you should obtain the relevant product disclosure statement (PDS) or seek personal financial advice before making any investment decisions.

Learn more

About SuperGuide

SuperGuide is Australia’s leading superannuation and retirement planning website. Learn more

Superguide Pty Ltd ATF Superguide Unit Trust as a Corporate Authorised Representative (CAR) is a Corporate Authorised Representative of Independent Financial Advisers Australia, AFSL 464629

  • Contact us
  • Advertise on SuperGuide
  • Careers

Before using this website

  • New to SuperGuide?
  • Terms and Conditions of Use
  • Financial Services Guide
  • Privacy Policy and Privacy Collection
  • Copyright Policy
  • Editorial Policy and Complaints
  • Disclaimer

  • SuperGuide Premium
  • Subscriber feedback
  • Sitemap
SuperGuide