• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

SuperGuide

Superannuation and retirement planning information

  • SuperGuide Premium
  • Account
  • Log In
  • SuperGuide Premium
  • Account
  • Log In
  • How super works
    • Super for beginners
    • Super rules
    • Employers guide to super
    • Super contributions
    • Super and tax
    • Accessing super
    • Super news
    • Women and super
    • Super tips and strategies
    • How-to guides
    • Super quizzes
    • Superannuation Q&As
    • Superannuation glossary
  • Super funds
    • Best performing super funds
    • Super fund rankings
    • Best performing pension funds
    • Pension fund rankings
    • Super fund average returns
    • Super investing strategies
    • Comparing super funds
    • Choosing a super fund
    • Choosing an investment option
    • Super fund fees
    • Insurance and super
    • Super fund profiles
  • SMSFs
    • SMSFs for beginners
    • SMSF administration
    • SMSF checklists
    • SMSF compliance
    • SMSF investing
    • SMSF pensions
    • SMSF strategies
    • SMSF Q&As
  • Plan your retirement
    • Retirement planning for beginners
    • When should I retire?
    • How long will I live?
    • How much super do I need?
    • Will I get the Age Pension?
    • How much will I spend in retirement?
    • Financial advice
    • Retiring overseas
    • Preparing for retirement
    • Retirement planning strategies
    • Retirement calculators and reckoners
  • In retirement
    • Income in retirement
    • Super lump sums
    • Super pensions
    • Age Pension
    • Working in retirement
    • Life in retirement
    • Senior concessions and services
    • Aged care
    • Estate planning
    • Super death benefits

Home / Super funds / Choosing an investment option / What is a growth asset? Time to set some standards

What is a growth asset? Time to set some standards

August 3, 2020 by Barbara Drury Leave a Comment

Reading time: 6 minutes

On this page

  • A standardised approach
  • A brief history
  • Case Study: Hostplus
  • The proposed solution
  • Industry response

As things stand, it’s left up to super funds to decide whether their investments should be classified as growth or defensive. This might seem arcane, and of little interest to the average fund member, but it has real implications when it comes to comparing funds and returns.

How so?

Your super fund’s exposure to growth assets is commonly used as shorthand for risk – the higher the level of growth assets, the higher the risk – although it is a rough approximation at best.

Even so, research groups such as ChantWest and SuperRatings use the information funds give them to put their investment options into categories such as Balanced, Growth and Defensive and rate their performance.

See SuperGuide article Balanced, Growth, Defensive: What’s in a name?

Financial advisers and individual investors then use these ratings to compare funds. The super fund regulator, the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) also uses these growth and defensive risk profiles as part of its heatmap analysis to identify poor performers.


Advertisement
SuperGuide Premium is ad-free

Yet there is no standard measure of risk to guide the way super funds classify their investments as growth or defensive. And this makes it near impossible to compare funds on a like-for-like basis.

A standardised approach

To bring some order to this free-for-all, an industry working group has spent over a year developing proposed standards for classifying growth and defensive components of super fund portfolios.

David Bell, who chaired the working group, says the challenge is to manage the competing tensions of providing a more nuanced way of classifying assets while minimising operational complexity for the funds. 

“Growth/defensive categorisation is one of those tough projects – it is complex, controversial and everyone has different views,” he says.

You can jump to their proposal below. But first, a little history.

A brief history

Historically, shares were in the growth basket while cash and bonds made up the defensive part of portfolios. That worked well enough up until the mid-1990s.

Compare super funds

Read more...

Advertisement

Since then, super funds have embraced a much broader range of investments and asset classes. These include unlisted property, unlisted infrastructure, private equity, hedge funds, high yield credit, long duration bonds and other forms of alternative debt.

All these new kids on the block have different growth and defensive characteristics. Sometimes, differences emerge within the same asset class.

For example, an investment in a commercial property with a secure tenant has a reliable income stream that could be regarded as defensive. While investment in a development property is a much riskier proposition, albeit with the potential for high growth. Yet both are property investments that once would have been lumped in the growth basket.

The problem

Currently, funds disclose the proportion of growth and defensive assets in their investment options, but not how they derive these figures. So a while back Chant West asked them.

The table below shows the responses of 32 not-for-profit funds (including 24 industry funds) and eight retail funds as at June 2018.

How super funds classify the growth component of non-traditional assets

Growth asset classification for not-for-profits

Unlisted propertyUnlisted infrastructureHedge fundsHigh yield / emerging market debtAlternative / other debt
100% growth1514633
51–100% growth34312
50% growth1113358
1–49% growth21102
0% growth10376

Growth asset classification for not-for-profits

Advertisement
Unlisted propertyUnlisted infrastructureHedge fundsHigh yield / emerging market debtAlternative / other debt
100% growth65030
51–100% growth11100
50% growth11111
1–49% growth00001
0% growth01222

Source: Chant West

Not all funds held assets in all sectors; and some did not provide a growth/defensive split for hedge funds and debt assets, which could fall either way depending on individual risk characteristics.

Even so, as you can see from the table, close to half the not-for-profit funds classed unlisted property and infrastructure as all growth (the traditional approach to these assets), and about 40% treated them as 50/50 growth/defensive.

Some funds break down the growth and defensive components of each asset, often by taking the expected capital growth as the growth component and income as the defensive component. But this is also a broad-brush approach, given that income and growth can both be variable, depending on the nature of the asset and market conditions.

By comparison, around 75% of retail funds classified unlisted property and infrastructure as all growth.

The classification of hedge funds and debt assets was more mixed by both groups of funds due to the wide range of risks within these asset classes.


Advertisement

The responses highlighted the inconsistent approach across and between fund sectors.


Case Study: Hostplus

Hostplus’ Balanced default option has a strategic asset allocation (actual allocations will vary depending on market conditions) of around 76% growth and 24% defensive. According to its website, the asset breakdown is as follows:

Asset class% of portfolio
Shares50%
Property13%
Infrastructure12%
Private equity8%
Credit7%
Alternatives5%
Diversified fixed interest0%
Cash5%
Growth76%
Defensive24%

As you can see from the table, if the traditional classification of defensive assets as cash and bonds were used, the portfolio would be 95% growth/5% defensive. Instead, Hostplus apportions growth and defensive components to each of its property, infrastructure, credit and alternative investments.

Hostplus chief investment officer Sam Sicilia says: “If you assume only cash and bonds are defensive, we would be 95:5 and we would get booted out of the (Balanced category of the performance) survey.”

In recent years, Hostplus has been among the top performing Balanced funds based on returns over multiple periods. While he argues they would still perform in the top percentile if they were labelled a High Growth fund, they would not stand out as much as they do now.

Sicilia says this would please critics who say funds like Hostplus game the system by not including unlisted property and infrastructure in their growth allocation. As the Chant West survey mentioned earlier shows, retail funds tend to invest in listed versions of these assets that are included in their growth allocation.

“Using a sporting analogy, you either beat the other teams in the competition or you get them booted out of the comp. Either way you win.”

For this reason, Sicilia believes the standardised classification of growth and defensive assets proposed by the Conexus working group (below) is unlikely to keep his detractors happy.


The proposed solution

As mentioned earlier, on 23 July 2020 a group of industry professionals released a set of standards to guide the way funds categorise the growth and defensive portions of their portfolios. They are calling on industry participants to comment by 28 September.

The group of eight includes representatives of retail and industry super funds as well as Chant West and SuperRatings. It is chaired by David Bell, a former fund manager and super fund chief investment officer who now runs the Conexus Institute.

They propose replacing the traditional method of scoring assets as 100% growth or 100% defensive with a more nuanced scoring system.

While equities (including private equity) would remain 100% growth, and cash and traditional fixed interest would remain 100% growth, other assets are broken down into growth and defensive components in a systematic way, rather than the ad hoc approach that exists now. These other asset sectors include unlisted property and infrastructure, alternative assets and high duration bonds.

Funds would also be able to choose a simple scoring system where funds have less than 15% exposure to a sector, and the option of a more detailed approach for higher exposures.

You can find the detailed proposal here. The table below is an excerpt to illustrate the proposed approach for some of the more problematic asset classes.

Proposed growth/defensive scoring for non-traditional investment sectors

Asset class / sectorSub-asset-class / sectorSimple scoringDetailed scoring
Unlisted propertyRisk category 180% growth100% growth
 Risk category 280% growth60% growth / 40% defensive
Unlisted infrastructureRisk category 180% growth100% growth
 Risk category 280% growth60% growth / 40% defensive
AlternativesIncludes emerging markets debt, hedge funds, forestry, agriculture commodities, catastrophe bonds, insurance-linked strategies75% growthApply risk scaling approach
Fixed interestHigh duration bonds60% growth / 40% defensiveApply risk scaling approach

Source: Conexus Institute

Industry response

David Bell strongly encourages the industry to actively participate in the consultation process. “All industry feedback is important. It would be great for an industry of this size to be able to develop collaborative solutions to industry problems.”

Early indications are that the superannuation industry broadly supports the proposal’s intent, if not the detail.

An APRA spokesperson said: “APRA recognises the benefits to all superannuation industry stakeholders, including members, of having a widely accepted, consistent approach to categorising and distinguishing between growth and defensive assets.

“On that basis, APRA supports industry-led efforts in this area and encourages all superannuation trustees and other interested stakeholders to participate in the consultation process.

“APRA is closely following the work of the Industry Working Group and intends to participate in the consultation process.”

In a recent interview with Investment Magazine, head of investments at Statewide Super Con Michalakis said: “It’s important we sit down and have a conversation about what is a growth asset. If we can get a code it will be a good outcome for the industry.”

Hostplus chief investment officer Sam Sicilia welcomes the work done by the Conexus working group but doubts it will solve the problem.

“We intend to lodge a submission but, I know that at the end of the day, the group is trying to solve a problem with a limited tool set. It still uses the words ‘growth’ and ‘defensive’, which is problematic because it ignores diversification,” he says.

Are you with a top performing super fund?

Click here to compare more than 90 Australian super funds, including returns, fees, features, awards and more.

Learn more about investment options in the following SuperGuide articles:

Balanced, Growth, Defensive: What’s in a name?

August 3, 2020

Choosing a super investment option

February 15, 2020

Is it time to change your super investment option?

January 1, 2020

How to change your investment option: 6 points to check before you switch

January 1, 2020

How to choose an investment option for your super pension

December 11, 2019

Risk profiling and your investment choice

May 22, 2019

Super funds mentioned in this article

Statewide Super (Statewide Superannuation Trust) Hostplus Superannuation Fund

Related topics

Choosing an investment option Super funds

IMPORTANT: All information on SuperGuide is general in nature only and does not take into account your personal objectives, financial situation or needs. You should consider whether any information on SuperGuide is appropriate to you before acting on it. If SuperGuide refers to a financial product you should obtain the relevant product disclosure statement (PDS) or seek personal financial advice before making any investment decisions. Comments provided by readers that may include information relating to tax, superannuation or other rules cannot be relied upon as advice. SuperGuide does not verify the information provided within comments from readers. Learn more

© Copyright SuperGuide 2009-21. Copyright for this article belongs to SuperGuide Pty Ltd, and cannot be reproduced without express and specific consent. Learn more

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

How super works
Super for beginners
Super rules
Employers guide to super
Super contributions
Super and tax
Accessing super
Super news
Women and super
Super tips and strategies
How-to guides
Super quizzes
Superannuation Q&As
Superannuation glossary
Super funds
Best performing super funds
Super fund rankings
Best performing pension funds
Pension fund rankings
Super fund average returns
Super investing strategies
Comparing super funds
Choosing a super fund
Choosing an investment option
Super fund fees
Insurance and super
Super fund profiles
SMSFs
SMSFs for beginners
SMSF administration
SMSF checklists
SMSF compliance
SMSF investing
SMSF pensions
SMSF strategies
SMSF Q&As
Plan your retirement
Retirement planning for beginners
When should I retire?
How long will I live?
How much super do I need?
Will I get the Age Pension?
How much will I spend in retirement?
Financial advice
Retiring overseas
Preparing for retirement
Retirement planning strategies
Retirement calculators and reckoners
In retirement
Income in retirement
Super lump sums
Super pensions
Age Pension
Working in retirement
Life in retirement
Senior concessions and services
Aged care
Estate planning
Super death benefits
Advertisement
Compare super funds

Footer

Important: Disclaimer

All information on SuperGuide is general in nature only and does not take into account your personal objectives, financial situation or needs.

You should consider whether any information on SuperGuide is appropriate to you before acting on it.

If SuperGuide refers to a financial product you should obtain the relevant product disclosure statement (PDS) or seek personal financial advice before making any investment decisions.

Learn more

About SuperGuide

SuperGuide is Australia’s leading superannuation and retirement planning website. Learn more

Superguide Pty Ltd ATF Superguide Unit Trust as a Corporate Authorised Representative (CAR) is a Corporate Authorised Representative of Independent Financial Advisers Australia, AFSL 464629

  • Contact us
  • Advertise on SuperGuide
  • Careers

Before using this website

  • New to SuperGuide?
  • Terms and Conditions of Use
  • Financial Services Guide
  • Privacy Policy and Privacy Collection
  • Copyright Policy
  • Editorial Policy and Complaints
  • Disclaimer

  • SuperGuide Premium
  • Subscriber feedback
  • Sitemap