Home / Retiree / Managing super in retirement / 10/30/60 rule: How investment returns shape your retirement income

10/30/60 rule: How investment returns shape your retirement income

It’s tough working out how to build a solid retirement income.

There are a lot of moving parts. It’s essential to understand where your money is likely to come from and how you can build on what you’ve already saved.

To add perspective to your thinking, a simple ‘rule of thumb’ about retirement income might assist you.

Where does your retirement income come from?

Research first undertaken in the United States some 30 years ago is still relevant for Australian super fund members today. It found for most people, around 90 cents of every dollar in retirement income comes from the earnings you achieve on your investments before and after retirement. Just 10 cents of each dollar of retirement income comes from the original contributions you made during your working life.

More surprisingly, around 60 cents in every dollar of retirement income comes from the investment earnings you achieve after you retire.

Jim Hennington, actuary at Jubilacion, has tested these calculations and adapted them for Australia’s superannuation system today (see below). He confirms the principles are still very relevant to Australians.

Need to know

According to the 10/30/60 Rule from the USA, your retirement income usually comes from the following sources:

  • 10% from the money you saved during your working years
  • 30% from the investment returns you achieve before you retire
  • 60% from the investment returns you achieve during your retirement.

Applying this to Australian super funds using appropriate tax settings, retirement age and economic assumptions, Hennington found the percentages are:

  • 15% from the money you saved during your working years
  • 35% from the investment returns you achieve before you retire
  • 50% from the investment returns you achieve during your retirement.

Although the actual percentages for each person will vary depending on their personal situation and the market conditions they live through, the principles are highly relevant to the way most people’s superannuation works over the course of their lifetime.

The practical implication is that earning a good investment return on your retirement savings is just as important, if not more important, than it was during your working life.

It’s all to do with the way investment returns work over the long term, and the impact of compound interest.

Background

The US study that gave rise to the 10/30/60 Rule was undertaken by a team led by world-renowned pension fund expert, D. Don Ezra in June 1989. It was based on research undertaken with defined benefit (DB) pension funds but was replicated with defined contribution (DC) funds. (These days most Australians are members of defined contribution funds, although many public servants are still in older defined benefit funds.)

The 10/30/60 Rule assumes a person joins their super fund at age 25 and contributes $1,000 per year, with this amount rising 4.75% every year after that until retirement. The person begins receiving a retirement income at age 65, and this rises 3% each year until death at age 90, when their account balance is nil. The investment return (net of fees and taxes) is assumed to be 7.8% every year.

Step 1 of 9

How well is your retirement income working for you?
Retirement income quiz

You’ve spent years building your retirement savings. Now it’s about understanding how that money is working for you.

Answer 7 quick questions to get a clear snapshot of where you stand and what to do next.

Does the 10/30/60 Rule apply to Australian retirees?

Hennington’s calculations for Australia assume the person joins a super fund at age 25 and contributes $7,000 per year (before contribution tax) with this amount rising 3.5% every year until retirement at age 67. They then begin drawing a retirement income that increases by 2.5% per year. The amount they draw gets calculated so their balance is zero when they reach age 92. While working, the assumed investment return is 6.5% per year (net of tax) less fees and charges of 0.7% per year. In retirement, the assumed return remains at 6.5% per year (assuming slightly more conservative investments but no tax) less fees and charges of 0.7%.

In Australia, based on these assumptions, their balance, contributions and net investment income look as follows:

AgeContributions $ per yr
after 15% tax
Start of year
$ balance
Investment income
$ per year
Drawings
$
255,9500
266,1586,127177
276,37412,840554
286,59720,180967
296,82828,1951,418
307,06736,9321,909
317,31446,4442,445
327,57056,7863,028
337,83568,0173,661
348,10980,2004,349
358,39393,4035,094
368,687107,6985,901
378,991123,1596,775
389,306139,8697,719
399,631157,9148,739
409,968177,3869,841
4110,317198,38311,029
4210,678221,01012,310
4311,052245,37813,689
4411,439271,60515,175
4511,839299,81716,773
4612,254330,14818,492
4712,682362,74020,339
4813,126397,74722,324
4913,586435,32824,455
5014,061475,65626,742
5114,553518,91429,196
5215,063565,29531,828
5315,590615,00734,649
5416,136668,27037,673
5516,700725,31740,911
5617,285786,39744,379
5717,890851,77448,092
5818,516921,72952,066
5919,164996,56256,317
6019,8351,076,58960,863
6120,5291,162,14965,725
6221,2481,253,60070,922
6321,9911,351,32476,476
6422,7611,455,72682,411
6523,5581,567,23688,750
6624,3821,686,31495,520
671,813,445102,749105,924
681,810,826103,305108,572
691,805,240102,986111,286
701,796,438102,484114,069
711,784,153101,783116,920
721,768,100100,868119,843
731,747,97699,720122,839
741,723,45898,321125,910
751,694,19996,652129,058
761,659,83294,691132,285
771,619,96492,417135,592
781,574,17789,805138,981
791,522,02586,829142,456
801,463,03283,464146,017
811,396,69579,679149,668
821,322,47275,445153,410
831,239,79170,728157,245
841,148,04065,494161,176
851,046,56959,705165,205
86934,68653,323169,335
87811,65546,304173,569
88676,69038,604177,908
89528,95930,176182,356
90367,57220,969186,915
91191,58710,930191,587
9200

If we focus on what happens in retirement, the sum of future drawings from age 67 (that is, the sum of the right-hand column of the table) was $3,618,127.

Slightly over half of this (50.1%) came from the balance they had at age 67 (which was $1,813,445) and the rest (49.9%) came from summing their investment returns after age 67 ($1,804,682).

In other words, half of their retirement income comes from investment returns after they’ve retired. Only half of their retirement income came from drawing down the balance they held at age 67.

Why do investment returns play such a big role?

Basically, as your balance grows, investment returns become a major source of cashflow. By age 41, the investment income in the above table is more than the contribution level. Most people’s super reaches a peak when they retire and start drawing money out for retirement. Depending on how much they draw each year, the balance often remains high, long into retirement.

In the retirement phase, the maths is working in a similar way to when you make standard payments on a mortgage over the 20-year or 25-year term of your home loan. During the early years, your mortgage payments consist mainly of interest – as the balance owing is high. Towards the end of the loan, as the balance owing reduces, your mortgage payments consist mainly of capital repayments.

It’s similar in retirement, your drawdowns in the early stages consist mainly of investment returns on your balance. Whereas later in retirement, as your balance reduces, your drawings mainly consist of the capital itself.

Risk and uncertainty

The above calculations are all based on fixed assumptions. This is a limitation of using simple projection models for retirement. The calculations assume a known ‘run out age’ and fixed rates of growth for investment returns and salary increases. In reality, none of these are known with certainty at all!

Retirees don’t know what future returns they will get. Nor do they know how long they will live. This means they cannot determine how much they can draw from super with any certainty. Depending on these factors, and the risk of negative returns close to retirement, the amount of drawings your super can sustain in retirement varies dramatically.

Nonetheless, instead of moving all your money into cash, which drastically reduces your investment income prospects, modern retirement models can take into account the probability of all possible outcomes. This means you can find out the level of retirement spending that you can enjoy with, say, 95% confidence that it’s sustainable for life – even if you live a long time, market returns aren’t favourable or living costs increase.

Conclusion: What does this mean for retirees?

Although choosing the right investment option or mix of assets for your super account is important during your working life, the above ‘rules of thumb’ show it is just as important in retirement.

As a retiree, you need to keep investing your nest egg throughout your retirement years with a carefully considered strategy balancing security, investment risk and good investment returns.

If you retire in your 60s, you might be in retirement for 20–30 years, and that means you need to take a longer-term view of your investments. You may wish to consider taking on some investment risk with at least part of your retirement savings with the aim of generating solid returns.

By including some growth assets (broadly shares and property) in your portfolio to provide enhanced returns, you may be able to defer the need to draw heavily on your capital amount.

History has shown growth assets usually have a better chance of delivering the good returns needed to fund your retirement income, even if you are drawing down on them at the same time. Modern modelling techniques help to trade off risk (running out of money) and return (a higher lifestyle or other goals) in the retirement phase.

Super tip

Being too conservative with all your investments in retirement could mean your money grows too slowly and you end up outliving your retirement savings.

Discover more about how long you can expect to live, and what it means for your super.

The modelling for this article was kindly provided by Jim Hennington, qualified actuary. Jim is co-founder of Jubilacion who provide an expert retirement modelling service for individuals. Jubilacion’s software helps people design retirement plans that take risk into account, based on their circumstances, decisions and goals.

SuperGuide members receive a 15% discount on Jubilacion’s services. Find out more.

Get independent guidance and practical tools to help you stay on track in retirement, make more informed decisions and keep up with rule changes that affect you.

Create free account

Trusted by 5,000+ members · Independent · Ad-free
Prefer full access? See what’s included in membership.

  • Trusted by 5,000+ members
  • Independent
  • Ad-free

About the author

Related topics,

IMPORTANT: All information on SuperGuide is general in nature only and does not take into account your personal objectives, financial situation or needs. You should consider whether any information on SuperGuide is appropriate to you before acting on it. If SuperGuide refers to a financial product you should obtain the relevant product disclosure statement (PDS) or seek personal financial advice before making any investment decisions. Comments provided by readers that may include information relating to tax, superannuation or other rules cannot be relied upon as advice. SuperGuide does not verify the information provided within comments from readers. Learn more

© Copyright SuperGuide 2008-26. Copyright for this guide belongs to SuperGuide Pty Ltd, and cannot be reproduced without express and specific consent. Learn more

Response

  1. Thank you for the article it shows how important the 65 to 83+ years old period investment is.

    The 10/30/60 Rule is from the 1980 with 10-15% interest rates. If one includes the 4% fees from that era, the ratio Deposit/BeforeRetirement/AfterRetirement/Fees becomes:
    8/14/52/26
    If one assumes the current 5% interest and and taking into consideration fees.
    The ratio Deposit/BeforeRetirement/AfterRetirement/Fees become
    at 2% fees: 19/20/38/23
    at 4% fees: 22/18/26/35
    So the winner is Fees/Admin – we can reduce our on fees.
    The real problem is TAX of 15% on the input and accumulation phase.
    Doesn’t sound much but is huge.

    Dave
    PS If anyone is interested I would be please to send them the spreadsheet of the calculations.

Leave a Reply